What to Prioritize During a Career Change: Title, Salary, or Values?

Jul 02, 2025

Every time I thought about changing careers, I spiraled. Should I go for a bigger title? Should I chase the higher paycheck? Or should I finally pick something that actually aligns with my values?

One of my clients called it the “career change panic triangle.” Pick one, and the other two start screaming at you.

Let’s talk about that. Because if you’re planning a career change and you’re stuck on what to prioritize, you’re not the only one second-guessing yourself every five minutes.

Why Career Clarity Should Drive Every Career Change

Most of the career changers I work with aren’t confused because they lack ambition. They’re confused because they’ve been making career decisions with the wrong map.

Career clarity isn’t about knowing the exact job title you want. It’s about knowing what matters to you before you pick a title, negotiate a salary, or sell yourself to another company.

I had a client who accepted a job that checked every box on paper. But two weeks in, she called me and said, "This isn’t it." What was missing? Alignment. Her work looked good on LinkedIn but felt wrong in real life.

That’s what happens when clarity is skipped. You just end up job-hopping in better clothes.

Prioritizing Job Title During a Career Change

A lot of people I talk to feel pressure to "level up." They think a more impressive title will finally prove their growth.

But job titles are tricky. I’ve seen someone go from coordinator to director in one move, and still feel like a glorified admin assistant. Titles don’t always reflect influence, autonomy, or respect.

If you're switching industries, title inflation can actually backfire. Some companies won’t know what your old title meant, and they might overestimate or underestimate your skills. One of my clients jumped into a “Senior Lead” role in a startup after leaving corporate. It sounded fancy but came with zero support and 10 different hats.

Titles can open doors, sure. But they can also trap you in work that doesn’t match what you’re ready for.

Prioritizing Salary During a Career Shift

Money matters. Especially if you’ve been underpaid or you're supporting a family. No shame in wanting a higher paycheck.

But here’s where salary trips people up: when it becomes the only goal.

I had a client who landed a $35K raise in her new role. She was thrilled for the first two months. By month three, she messaged me, "I hate waking up for this." The money was great, but the values clash was loud. Meetings full of performative politics. No feedback loop. No mission.

You can absolutely find career change paths that don’t require a pay cut. But chasing a number without checking the culture, workload, or team? That’s a fast path to burnout with benefits.

Prioritizing Values During Your Career Transition

This one doesn’t get hyped enough, but it’s the one that creates lasting satisfaction.

Values don’t mean fluff. Values mean: Do you feel safe speaking up? Do you believe in the work you’re doing? Do you see yourself growing without losing your sanity?

One client of mine left a fancy tech company because she couldn’t ignore how much leadership dodged accountability. She found a new role that paid slightly less, but offered flexibility, mentorship, and room to build something real. Six months later, she told me, "I finally feel like myself again."

When your job reflects your values, everything else becomes easier: communicating, setting boundaries, making decisions. It’s not magic. It’s alignment.

Can You Have All Three in Your Career Change?

Yes—but not always at the same time.

Here’s what I tell clients: You can get the title, the salary, and the values. But most of the time, one will lead and the others will follow.

Early in your pivot, values should lead. Why? Because they’ll guide you toward the right fit. Once you're in the right environment, the money and growth tend to catch up.

Trying to get all three in your first role post-pivot is like trying to cook a gourmet meal on a microwave timer. It’ll stress you out, and probably flop.

New Priorities Come with New Challenges

People rarely talk about the emotional tax of career change. You’re not just switching jobs. You’re rewriting your story. And that can feel scary, especially if you've built your identity around a certain role or industry.

One of my clients broke down during a resume review. She kept saying, “What if none of this counts in my new field?” We worked through that. We reframed her experience. She landed interviews the next month. Her past didn’t disqualify her—it gave her a unique angle.

Shifting careers often means shifting mindset. You’re allowed to change your priorities. You're allowed to want more than a paycheck.

How to Know What to Prioritize First

Start with clarity. Not job boards. Not networking events. Clarity.

Ask yourself: What do I want to feel in my next role? What do I want my work to give me besides a paycheck? What would make me feel proud to log in?

Then look at your current pain points. If your biggest frustration is being ignored at work, values might be your top priority. If you're constantly broke, salary could lead. If your confidence is low, a title bump might give you leverage.

I built a free career change masterclass to walk through this exact process. It’s for anyone stuck in decision limbo.

Rewriting Your Career Story Takes Intention

One mistake I see often is rushing into new roles that “look better on paper.” I’ve done it myself. I once took a role that gave me a shiny new title and a decent raise. But by month four, I felt like I was constantly proving I belonged. I wasn’t building. I was surviving.

Don’t base your decision on what sounds good in a group chat. Build something that sounds good in your gut.

Take your time. Get support. Stop trying to check all three boxes in one leap. That’s not clarity—that’s pressure. And pressure makes people settle.

FAQs: Career Change

How do I decide on a career change

Ask yourself a few honest questions:

What feels wrong in my current role?
What kind of work excites me or feels meaningful?
What do I want more (or less) of in my day-to-day?

Talk to people in roles you're curious about. Make a list of industries or companies that match your values. You don’t have to figure it all out at once—just get clear on what you want next and take small steps toward it.

How to prepare for a career change

Start by getting clear on your goals. Update your résumé and LinkedIn to reflect where you want to go—not just where you’ve been. Network with people in your target field. Practice your interview skills. If you’re feeling stuck, consider working with a career coach to create a step-by-step plan that keeps you focused and confident.

About Career Clarity coach

Theresa White, Career Clarity Expert, 5x Certified Career Coach, and the Founder of Career Bloom, is known for her expertise in guiding people to get unstuck and find the direction they need to move forward in their careers—fast. In a time when so many people are re-evaluating their work, Theresa offers actionable insights that empower clients to identify their true strengths and pursue work that genuinely aligns with their goals.

Theresa’s clients often call her sessions “epiphanies” and “transformational.” She brings immediate clarity to career goals, helping people unlock a deep understanding of what makes work fulfilling for them. Past participants consistently describe her approach as “spot on” and an “answer to questions they’d been asking for weeks.”

Theresa’s approach is empathetic yet practical, and she’s known for empowering clients with a clear direction in as little as 30 days, guaranteeing results.

Connect with Theresa on LinkedIn, listen to the Career Clarity Unlocked Podcast, or schedule your free 30-minute career clarity consultation.

Ready to Make a Career Change That Actually Feels Good?

You don’t have to keep guessing.

If you want a role that pays well, fits your lifestyle, and doesn’t feel like selling your soul, it starts with clarity.

Start with the Career Clarity Masterclass. Or book a free consultation call and let’s figure it out together.

Your next job doesn’t have to be perfect. It just has to be yours.

👉 Ready for career clarity in record time? Request a free consultation with me today.

Let's chat